[TYPED LETTER, SIGNED, WITH SEVERAL PENCIL EMENDATIONS, FROM THEODORE ROOSEVELT AS ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF THE NAVY TO CAPTAIN CHARLES O'NEIL, CHIEF OF THE ORDNANCE BUREAU, DISCUSSING THE DISCRETION NEEDED BY THE NAVY DEPARTMENT IN THE WAKE OF THE EXPLOSION OF THE U.S.S. MAINE]
by Roosevelt, Theodore
- Used
- Condition
- See description
- Seller
-
New Haven, Connecticut, United States
Payment Methods Accepted
About This Item
The explosion that sent the Maine to the bottom of Havana Harbor remains controversial to this day. The morning after the event Captain Philip R. Alger, a math professor at the United States Naval Academy, chemist, and explosives expert, put up a bulletin at the Navy Department claiming the explosion came from inside the Maine. Roosevelt immediately ordered Alger to remove the bulletin until an official inquiry could be performed. In the present letter, written thirteen days after the explosion, Roosevelt writes to Captain O'Neil, head of the Ordnance Bureau, and references the incident with Alger, asking:
"...don't you think it inadvisable for Prof. Alger to express opinions in this matter? Captain Bradford [chief of the Bureau of Equipment] has all along believed that Prof. Alger is absolutely in error in his views. He believes the explosion was not accidental. Captain Clover [head of the Office of Naval Intelligence] is inclined to the same belief. I should certainly feel that it was not advisable for either of them to make public any such statement, and it seems to me that it is inadvisable for Prof. Alger to make these statements."
Roosevelt then asks O'Neil to relate "your views about the matter unofficially," adding that "Mr. Alger cannot possibly know anything about the accident."
That last sentence is curious. Conspiracy theorists might latch onto the notion that in calling the incident an "accident," Roosevelt is perhaps trying to put forth or propagate the mine theory less than two weeks after the affair. He is at least trying to control the message coming from the Navy Department, as he writes:
"All the best men in the Department agree that, whether possible or not, it certainly is possible [underlined] that the ship was blown up by a mine which might, or might not, have been towed under her; and when we have a court sitting to find out these facts it seems to me to the last point inadvisable for any person connected with the Navy Department to express his opinion publicly in the matter, and especially to give elaborate reasons for one side or the other. The fact that Mr. Alger happens to take the Spanish side and to imply that the explosion was probably due to some fault of the Navy, whether in the Construction Department, or among the officers, has, of course, nothing to do with the matter."
The "court sitting" Roosevelt mentions here occurred the next month. A U.S. Navy Court of Inquiry ruled in March 1898 that the Maine was destroyed by a mine, but did not identify a culprit. The mine theory prevailed in the century following the sinking of the Maine, even after a second inquiry following the raising of the Maine in 1911. However, in 1976, following the erosion of trust in the government and its military resulting from the Vietnam War (a conflict accelerated by a naval incident at the Gulf of Tonkin in 1964), a group of American naval investigators led by Admiral Hyman Rickover concluded that the explosion on the Maine was indeed caused by spontaneous combustion in the ship's coal bins that ignited its stock of ammunition. It seems that Professor Alger was correct from the very beginning. We will not go so far as to ask "What did TR know, and when did he know it?," but the mine theory certainly seems like a fait accompli here, and perhaps the story the U.S. Navy and the federal government as a whole wanted people to believe.
Perhaps ironically, and certainly fortuitously, the explosion of the Maine helped precipitate the very war from which Roosevelt's legend grew to atmospheric levels. TR and his Rough Riders fought bravely in Cuba in the summer of 1898, and their exploits earned them a hero's welcome upon their return. Shortly thereafter, in the Election of 1900, Roosevelt rode his notoriety from the Spanish-American War all the way to the White House.
Roosevelt's original manuscript version of the present letter is held in his papers at the Library of Congress. H. Richard Dietrich purchased the present document for $287.50 from a Charles Hamilton auction on May 21, 1965. It has remained in the Dietrich American Foundation since then.
Details
- Bookseller
- William Reese Company (US)
- Bookseller's Inventory #
- WRCAM57029
- Title
- [TYPED LETTER, SIGNED, WITH SEVERAL PENCIL EMENDATIONS, FROM THEODORE ROOSEVELT AS ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF THE NAVY TO CAPTAIN CHARLES O'NEIL, CHIEF OF THE ORDNANCE BUREAU, DISCUSSING THE DISCRETION NEEDED BY THE NAVY DEPARTMENT IN THE WAKE OF THE EXPLOSION OF THE U.S.S. MAINE]
- Author
- Roosevelt, Theodore
- Book Condition
- Used
- Quantity Available
- 1
- Place of Publication
- Washington, D.C.
- Date Published
- February 28, 1898.
Terms of Sale
William Reese Company
About the Seller
William Reese Company
About William Reese Company
With a catalogued inventory of over thirty thousand items, and a general inventory of over sixty-five thousand items, we are among the leading specialists in the fields of Americana and world travel, and maintain a large and eclectic inventory of literary first editions and antiquarian books of the 18th through 20th centuries.
We issue frequent, and substantial, catalogues in our fields of specialization, and we are equipped to produce smaller lists devoted to specific subjects with ease in response to requests.
Glossary
Some terminology that may be used in this description includes: