Boston, 1857 (manuscript proof approval verso): Framed period engraving examined out of frame

Details:
19th c. hand colored steel plate engraving after watercolor by John W. Hill, Boston, 1853 with gilt wood frame and glass as found and removed from frame
Charles Mottram, [London]Engraver
McQueen [London], Printer
Paul & Dominic Colnaghi & Co., London, Smith Brothers & Co., New York, at Sowle & Wards, 14 Summer St., Boston, Paris F Delarue Rue J.J. Rouseau 18, Publishers, B.[enjamin].F.[ranklin] Smith, Copyright 1857, District of Massachusetts
dimensions: print image without lettering: 38 3/4" x 24 3/4"
dimensions: print sheet :42" x 28 1/2"
condition: as found, removed from gilt wood frame, original complex bright colors, period paper, ample margins, paper lightly toned, two areas of vertical toning in the image, manuscript pencil on back of print "N.S. Dearborn, 24 School Street, Boston" and "Good", visible engraving plate impression in print sheet
Description:
This distinctively inscribed example of the 1857 print Boston, is a period, colored steel plate engraving by Charles Mottram (1807-1876), one of London's most esteemed plate engravers who has translated in the medium of engraving the large 1853 water color painting Boston by British born American artist John William Hill (1812-1879) who apprenticed as a youth with his father John Hill, an English aquatint engraver. 1/ J.W. Hill's expansive 1853 view of busy Boston Harbor is from a slightly elevated waterfront vantage point likely in East Boston and includes Boston and vicinity. It is midday and bright, the season warm enough for shirtsleeves, in the print's foreground one fellow is at work bringing up a net at water's edge, another in a brimmed hat holds a pointed pole and a third lounges nearby next to an empty barrel and basket. Just off shore young men at work in two separate very small boats pass each other. The artist places a floating wooden barrel in the foreground scene to capture and then guide the viewer's gaze straight out to the horizon where the distant golden dome of the Massachusetts State House atop Beacon Hill anchors a composition bounded by the Great Blue Hills to the south and the Bunker Hill Monument in Charlestown to the north. In the middle ground ships of all sizes and types traverse the harbor, under sail, steam and manpower. This visually dynamic urban portrait defines Boston in 1853 by its fully built out harbor and densely developed wharves of brick and granite warehouses that present the city's mercantile face to the world. Factory chimneys and church spires throughout the city attest to higher aspirations. This view by a naturalized American artist 2/ may ironically have turned the tables on typical 18th c. British (and even Paul Revere's 1770 print) views of Boston as if from the deck of a British ship arriving from England to trade with its colony. Hill's artistic portrait of Boston is of a thriving American port city.

Creating the 1857 Boston print from J.W.Hill's painting required what author Anthony Dyson in Pictures to Print describes in detail as a complex "collaborative" process organized by the master plate printer who pulled the successful print only after a lengthy process that depended on his professional network of craftsmen and tradesmen3/ Our edition of the Boston print has the imprint in the lower right margin "Printed by McQueen" one of London's preeminent fine art engraved plate printers who was also internationally recognized. 4/ The Boston print is further identified as "Engraved by C. Mottram" immediately below the neat line in the bottom right corner. (see photograph of plate) Mottram's task was no less complex than McQueen's: Mottram captured the aesthetics of J.W. Hill's brush strokes and the color tones of watercolor with multiple steel engraving techniques to create line, texture, form, shading and light . The atmosphere of the sky, the shimmer of light and reflections of objects on the water, the ripple of the tide are rendered by the engraver's use of intaglio and the plate printer's understanding of how to ink, wipe and apply color to the plate to synthesize all elements of the new art form. In 1855, the French Jurors of the 1855 Paris Exhibition Universelle who awarded McQueen the First Class Medal remarked that the plate printer's pulling of a print realizes the artist's fine art as the performance of a composer's score realizes the music.5/

There are two manuscript features on the verso of this Boston, 1857 print discovered when the print was examined out of its frame. These manuscript notations suggest this print is a scarce signed client proof. On the verso in period 19th c. pencil script is "N.S. Dearborn, 124 School Street, Boston" who is Nathaniel S. Dearborn a Boston engraver and plate printer at this Boston business address. 6/ The second pencil script "Good" is of a similar period hand. This format of signature and terms of approval or correction are typical of a client's approval of a proof print pulled by the plate printer. Who might be the client? The publisher line on the Boston print includes a New York, London and Paris publisher and the phrase "at Sowle and Wards" (sic). Perhaps this Boston picture seller is the client. Our print is an American export edition printed by McQueen for the Smith publishers. The Boston, Massachusetts copyright holder is B.F. Smith who may have engaged or partnered with the Boston firm Sowle & Ward to handle sales of this print.

An American print seller of an imported English print could only proof its edition by traveling to London, or with greater practicality by relying on the expertise of a well regarded local plate printer to advise on its quality. To proof the McQueen sample of the Boston color print, Dearborn would have been a reputable Boston plate printer and engraver to perform this task. Thus one explanation for the period 19th c. manuscript inscriptions by N.J. Dearborn on the verso of our print is that he was reviewing the proof for his client Sowle & Ward and giving his approval to proceed with the business of selling the McQueen edition, to be priced at a premium for being a colored engraving with the vanity imprint "Proof" in the lower front margin. Sowle & Ward was a picture framer even before it became a picture gallery and art dealer with additional reasons to do business with the Smith Brothers who were major American 19th c. print publishers.

The manuscript terms observed on the back of our print are not to be equated, and vice versa, with the imprint "Proof" on the front of the 19th c. McQueen edition. The printed term "Proof" on the McQueen print's lower left margin is a 19th c. publisher's conceit used to bring a higher retail price for the edition, just as a colored engraving was priced higher than a black and white engraving. Both black and white and color editions of Boston, 1857 carry the imprint "Proof" and this is a publisher's conceit that does not, without client manuscript approval on the sheet itself, elevate the print from being part of a commercial print run.

The business relationships that led to the publishing of J.W. Hill's picture as a print are another element of its history. The Smith Brothers of New York, including Benjamin Franklin Smith who was for some time based in Boston as well, were major 19th century publishers of American city views. Many of their publishing projects involved American artists who created "pictures to print" and the literature suggests that most of the Smith Brothers publishing involved lithograph city views. Please see John Reps for a definitive discussion of this 19th American art form.

The Smith archives including daybooks are at the American Antiquarian Society. Further research of the Boston print may therefore be continued with this original source material.

This 19th c. engraving of J.W. Hill's water color painting Boston, with the Mottram imprint, the McQueen imprint, Bostonian B.F. Smith's copyright and manuscript notations by Boston plate printer N.S. Dearborn approving the print illustrates the burgeoning mid-1850's transatlantic business collaboration in the fine art print trade. This remarkable example of the Boston print also represents a collaboration of that decade's fine artists in water color, copper, steel and plate printing.

Notes:
1.John William Hill's Boston | Graphic Arts2. John W. Hill began exhibiting his water color paintings at age 17. He was an apprentice to his Father John Hill, an aquatint engraver. In 1834-5 J.W. Hill was commissioned to paint American urban portraits by the New York Geological Survey that included topography and city features. In America, Hill painted four city views before 1840, two in 1845 and 4 others by 1852. See Reps below. Hill painted Boston in 1853. Thus, Hill's watercolor of Boston and his other city views involved detailed field work and are intended to be accurate contemporary portrayals geographically, architecturally and as to the character of the city. The details in the Boston print are not accidental. Perhaps the youthful "sailors" in the foreground are a metaphor for a youthful, industrializing America at work and at leisure.
3. Anthony Dyson's book is based on his study of original source material the Thomas Ross and Sons. These records include generations of London's premier engraving and printing houses. The book was invaluable in coming to some understanding of the artistry of picture engraving and printing, an art apart from the drawings, paintings and watercolors represented in their new medium.

Dyson writes that the McQueen firm was likely founded in the late 18th c. and by the 1850's was owned by the three McQueen brothers William Benjamin McQueen, John Henry McQueen, Frederick Charles McQueen. The family firm name evolved several times in the 19th and 20th century. Dyson, citing others p.43 estimated the firm by the late 1850's to be operating 25 to 30 presses. McQueen is the printer's name perhaps most frequently seen on nineteenth-century plates.

Mr. Lindsay E.C. Nutbrown, principal of Thomas Ross Limited, kindly corresponded with me 11/23/21 about the Boston plate now owned by his firm, including as a courtesy his photographs of the steel plate as waxed and stored. He explained that contemporary prints pulled from the plate do not include the term "Proof" or "Printed by McQueen" in the margin, as the terms have been chalked out.
4. William Henry McQueen, 1855 received note and the First Class Medal at the 1855 Paris Exposition Universelle. The French jurors recognized how the plate printer is often underappreciated, given that the plate printer's work is what generates credit for the engraver "car le tirage est a la gravure ce que l'execution musicale est a la composition." Dyson, p.9 citing the Juror's report of the 1855 Paris Exposition Universelle.
5. See Boston Business Directory 1859.
6. [The Boston print publisher Sowle and Ward at 14 Summer Street, Boston was a picture dealer. See The Historical Picture Gallery, Or, Scenes and Incidents in American History, vol.5 by John R. Chapin, 1856, p.338 for a full page advertisement of Sowle and Ward "displaying paintings by American & Foreign artist" and "The earliest impressions of all Modern Engravings in advance of European publication." The 1856 advertisement is from the 14 Summer Street address. The firm ownership changed and the firm name became the Doll and Richards Gallery. Beth A. Treadway provides the history of the firm in her article, "The Doll and Richards Gallery", Archives of American Art Journal, vol 15, no. 1[Smithsonian American Art Museum, Smithsonian Institution, University of Chicago.]

Bibliography:
Anthony Dyson, Pictures to Print The nineteenth-century engraving trade
Farrand Press, London, 1984
John W. Reps, Views and Viewmakers of Urban America, Lithographs of Towns and Cities in the United States and Canada, Notes on the Artists and Publishers, and A Union Catalog of their Work, 1825-1925, University of Missouri Press, Columbia 1984
Imprint, John Hill artist, Vol.4, no.1 (Apr.1979)

______________________________________________________________________

Shipping Charges for gilt wood picture frame and glass are at Buyer's expense. Frame with glass are included in the purchase price. These items may also be picked up by Buyer at Original Antique Maps.