The Promise Hardcover - 2014

Media reviews

Inspired by Jean Giono’s 1953 story, L’homme qui plantait des arbres, this tale is a sturdy one that is made even more emphatic by Davies’ terse writing style. The text is heightened in every way by Carlin’s outstanding mixed-media artwork.
—Booklist (starred review)

A message of hope infuses Davies's story... In her first picture book, Carlin creates a chalky, ashy landscape, which she gradually peppers with specks of color as the girl plants the acorns... Davies's parable-like narrative leaves a quietly powerful impression while avoiding preaching.
—Publishers Weekly

The illustrations turn to glorious full color as the world becomes a better place. The endpapers reflect the change from a sad story at the beginning to the positive, life-changing event at the end. A thoughtful book, told with simplicity, with a poignant message.
—School Library Journal

[An] earnest parable on how nature will provide an easy cure for the physical and moral sterility of urban life.
—Kirkus Reviews

A picture book that at first seems dystopic but is ultimately about the healing power of nature. ... Carlin opens with scratchy illustrations of harsh cityscapes colored gray and brown. Gradually, the pictures grow softer with hints of green and dashes of red and blue, until we see full bursts of color, not just from trees and flowers, but from within the people themselves.
—The Horn Book

The striking mixed-media illustrations complement the text nicely: Carlin’s work echoes Sweet’s in Bryant’s A Splash of Red in its use of interesting perspective, sketchy details layered on top of backgrounds, and hand-lettering throughout to evoke a child’s-eye view of the world. ... The book’s lyricism does mean it’s lovely when read aloud, making this a possible choice as a green-themed and sensitive bedtime story.
—Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books

Citations

• Booklist, 05/01/2014, Page 94
• Booklist Ed Choice Youth, 01/01/2015, Page 17
• Bulletin of Ctr for Child Bks, 05/01/2014, Page 0
• Horn Book Magazine, 05/01/2014, Page 62
• Hornbook Guide to Children, 07/01/2014, Page 0
• Kirkus Reviews, 03/01/2014, Page 0
• New York Times Book Review, 11/09/2014, Page 30
• Publishers Weekly, 04/14/2014, Page 0
• School Library Journal, 04/01/2014, Page 118