View Our 2020 Holiday Gift Guide

We made holiday shopping easy: browse by interest, category, price or age in our bookseller curated gift guide.

Shop Now
Skip to content

Biblio logo: Used, Rare and Collectible Books for Sale

The Old Mill Bookshop


The Old Mill Bookshop specializes in Americana, Classics, Fine Sets, Literature, Manuscripts, Original Art, Prints, Sporting Books.

About The Old Mill Bookshop

Founded in 1978 by James Cummins, the firm has grown to include two New Jersey locations as well as the main store at 699 Madison Avenue. The Madison avenue store is an oasis for book-lovers, a quiet and pleasantly furnished book room with a carefully chosen, expertly catalogued and broad-based selection of fine and rare books, autographs, manuscripts, and works of art.

Biblio Member Since

The Old Mill Bookshop

430 Sandshore Road
Unit 2
Phone: (908) 979-3360

Terms of sale for The Old Mill Bookshop

30 day return guarantee, with full refund including original shipping costs for up to 30 days after delivery if an item arrives misdescribed or damaged.

Payment Methods Accepted

  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • American Express
  • Discover
  • Paypal
The Old Mill Bookshop store photo

Browse books by author

Browse books by title